Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs

Pages

Monday, March 1, 2010

My Take on Telangana Issue !

For the last few months, Telangana and whole Andhra Pradesh are getting boiled in this turmoil. Everyone has an opinion and so do I..and here it is.

I’m a Telanganite, born in Warangal, brought up in Hyderabad. My wife is from Coastal Andhra and I have a lot of loved ones from that area, my brother in law is from Rayalaseema and I have spent 4 years of my life in Rayalaseema (engineering in Kurnool). So I feel I have some kind of attachment towards all areas of AP.

Since November, a lot of people asked me “Do you support separate Telangana movement or Samaikhyandhra Movement? “. Huh....now do I need to support or believe in one of these movements? Friends, let me tell you that for me “Both these movements are sooooo UNREAL”. I don’t want to be part of either movements or political gimmicks.

To those who support separate Telangana movement:



  • Do you think your life will change if separate state is formed? What has separate state to do with development? Let’s assume for a while that all those statistics about backwardness of Telangana are correct. But how can you assume that a new state, a new CM can change things? There are some inherent issues which can never be solved by changing boundaries of the state. The only group of Telangana that would get benefitted would be political fraternity and nobody else. Get it straight.



  • Do you think there would be no differences among various areas of Telangana? When we say that Telangana is backward compared to Andhra, so is Adilabad compared to Hyderabad. So once Telangana state is divided, shall we start a new movement for separate Adilabad or Nizamabad as they are more backward compared to Hyderabad or Warangal? Then a separate state for mandals, towns??? Where will this end? Any answers????



  • Do you honestly feel that you don’t need any cultural exchange from Andhra people? Can you let go your love and passion for Telugu film industry, media, radio, Kuchipudi art form and other forms of entertainment which is predominantly sustained by people of Andhra origin?



  • Can you start accepting the fact that pilgrimage centres like Tirumala, Srisailam, Annavaram, Sinhachalam and beautiful cities like Vizag, breathtaking scenes of Godavari districts, culinary delicacies of Krishna and Guntur don’t belong to us anymore?
    You may answer that all these don’t matter if we get our own Telangana. But brothers, just realize that we may get our own state of Telangana, but in this bargain, we will loose a lot, and a part of our identity too. Is it worth?


  • To those who support Samaikhyandhra:



  • Don’t you think that this so called Samaikhyandhra movement has been started by vested interests only to claim Hyderabad and all statements regarding “unity of Telugu people” are fake?



  • I heard people saying that Telangana without Hyderabad or Andhra`s contribution is like a begging bowl. Do you know that
    - Most of the flow area of R. Godavari, R. Krishna is in Telangana and if Almatti saga is repeated in separate Telangana, Andhra can no more claim itself as a granary of rice. Period.
    - Legacy or heritage of Telugu people roots back to Kakatiya Empire flourished in Warangal. There is no other place in AP which reflects Telugu grandeur or heritage as much as Warangal does.
    -Singareni Collieries produce coal for most of South India and employs some 80,000 people;Ramagundam boasts one of the India`s largest thermal power station which produces electricity to many areas of South India.Ranga Reddy district is one of the most industrially developed districts with resources which can support large scale industries. Sirpur, Nirmal and lot of places support mid and small scale industries.
    - Bhadrachalam, the second most revered pilgrim center, Basar the only Saraswathi temple in India attact thousands of devotees.
    - If you still feel that Telangana is only about Hyderabad, think again buddy.



  • Hyderabad: The bone of contention. My friends from Coastal Andhra are heard saying that they are the people who developed Hyderabad. A small piece of information for all those who come from this school of thought
    - Hyderabad is a city with history of more than 400 years. It was the richest area of British India, well before anybody can think of "developing it"
    - People from Arabic world came, conquered and built state of the art universities (Osmania), hospitals, reservoirs (Gandipet, Himayat Sagar), monuments (Charminar), improved the way of life of Hyderabadis well before there were similar facilities in the rest of the country. But they never claimed that "only they developed" Hyderabad.
    - People from Britain came, conquered and built railways, made Secunderabad the headquarters of South Central Railways, established convent schools and missionaries, built roads, highways and raised the standard of living. But they never claimed that "only they developed" Hyderabad. - Marwadis, Gujaratis, Parsis, Sindhis came to establish various businesses. So did people from Andhra, Rayalaseema and also from other parts of Telangana.
    - Everybody contributed to the development of Hyderabad, but...but...nobody did it with the noble intention of "developing Hyderabad". They did it for their own livelihood and prosperity. Dare to disagree?
    - Hyderabad is not developed only because it is a capital of Andhra Pradesh. If that’s the logic, how can Mumbai be a commercial and entertainment capital of India instead of Delhi? And how can New York be a financial capital and Los Angeles the entertainment capital of US, instead of Washington DC? Development occurs where there are resources.



  • How many people from Andhra or other parts of AP accept Telangana slang, culture as their culture. Telangana slang is always and only subject to ridicule and in movies, used only by comedians and villains. Even our very own Megastar did not / could not use the Telangana / Hyderabadi slang in Shankardada series though the hero of original version in Hindi used mumbayya slang. May be because "people won`t accept that" and the very people now talk about "unity of Telugu people and one state for all Telugu people". When KCR does his drama of hunger strike unto death or when Lagadapati Rajagopal performs his share of acting, they are trying to become Demi-Gods or future CMs of their respective areas and to support them in their political ambitions, people like us become fools and few people die too. Pathetic !


  • So it doesn`t make any sense for me to support either separate Telangana or Samaikhyandhra movement. I always belong to Andhra Pradesh and I wish all the people of the state respect each other and live with each other.

    I would love to sing "maa telugu thalli ki malle poodanda" and also recite "naa Telangana koti ratnala veena". I love my identity as an Indian, as an Andhraite, as a Telugu speaking person and as a Telanganite.
    Jai Andhra, Jai Telangana, Jai Rayalaseema (for me Samaikhyandhra is no more a good word). Your comments?

    4 comments:

    santhosh manduva said...

    I accept with what u have said .. the thing is

    1 . U have said that .. But how can you assume that a new state, a new CM can change things?

    I say .. for example as a state AP is been allocated with a budget of approx . 1 lakh crores .. in that to my knowledge around 20 lakh crores is being spent on Telangana region .. whereas in separate TELANGANA is formed a separate qouta will be allocated to Telangana .. for example .. as our region is around 42 % in AP .. we may be allocated with atleast 40 crores .. so . definetely there is a chance of we getting more funds than now .. for now forget how much of those 40 crores will be spent on public ..

    It has been proved that Rest of AP apart from Telangana is getting more funds ..

    Case 1 : NABARD .. AP - 120 crores
    Telangana - 9 crores

    Case 2 : Some school program .. forgot the name

    Anantapur - 600 crores

    Telangana - 20 crores

    and one more thing chandu anna .. u have asked

    Can you let go your love and passion for Telugu film industry, media, radio, Kuchipudi art form and other forms of entertainment which is predominantly sustained by people of Andhra origin?
    Can you start accepting the fact that pilgrimage centres like Tirumala, Srisailam, Annavaram, Sinhachalam and beautiful cities like Vizag, breathtaking scenes of Godavari districts, culinary delicacies of Krishna and Guntur don’t belong to us anymore?

    I say .. i'll njoy culinary delicacies od guntur and krishna as i 'll njoy Rajasthani chat and bengai sweets ..!!

    I would vist thirumala and simhachalam as i visit Bengaluru or Mumbai ..!!

    B'cos at the end of the day we are all INDIANS and Andhra nd Rayalaseema is also in INDIA ..!! :D


    1. If TELANGANA movement is a political gimmick .. why would public including intellectuals , employees , farmers , students , professors and ppl frm all sects take part in this so called political gimmick ..

    2 . Do u feel SAMAIKYANDRA is a movement .. i say its to keep a check against TELANGANA ..!! Any of u go and ask an political science professor from ANDHRA .. what can be called a movement ..!! To my knowledge a movement shld have some history , background , cause , sacrifices etc etc ..!! And the funniest thing is .. in the whole world so far SAMAIKYANDRA is the only movement which has born and started in 14 DAYS .. i repeat 14 DAYS ..

    And moreover .. if we TELANGANAITES are no more interested in living together . who are those SAMAIKYANDRA walas to fight for being together .. trash .. no way ..!!

    And one suggestion for ppl who are fighting for SAMAIKYADRA .. there is no point if u shout SAMAIKYANDRA is Andhra or Rayalaseema .. come to TELANGANA .. or ask ur so called leaders rajagopal or kavuri to come to TELANGANA and ask them to explain to us .. why shld we live together ..!!

    And lastly no one can stop TELANGANA .. what they can do is only delay it .. bcos no political party who stand against TELANGANA will win a single seat in the coming by elections or 2014 general elections ..!!

    And u all know this is a conditional merger .. while the time of merging it has been declared that at any point of time if both don't like being together the state can be divided ..!!




    Andhra people are claimimg that they developed hyderabad .. they forgot that they came for developing themseleves rather than coming for developing Hyderabad .. and stats say Hyderabad is been developed even bfore Andhra ppl strted migrating here ..!!

    And thet say we are brothers .. i jus put a question to them .. what have u did wen ur brothers have been striving for basic needs ?? what have u did when ur bothers are sacrificing their lives ?? Is there any brother in this world who njoys when his brother is struggling in all aspects ?? How many have u brothers participated in the funeral of martyrs who have laid their lives for TELANGANA ??

    Sorry if i have hurt anyone ..

    Chandu said...

    Santhosh,

    thanks for your comment. I agree with your statistics, but we can never assume that funds coming in will be used for development; Further there are many issues which are not linked just with funds.

    We can't be naive enough to believe politicans who start movements due to political unemployment can strive for real development. Chenna reddy started a more emotional movement and later dropped the idea when he was made CM of AP. No politician is an exception.

    Coming to the point of treating Andhra and Rayalaseema just as other parts of India would not be easy as there would be many emotional tensions, credibility issues. Though you like Rajastani food or Mumbai, you can't claim those to be "yours". Some Raj Thackeray may be after your life, can't rule out.

    If you ask me why intellectuals, others professionals support this movement, they are doing it with some kind of "hope". Pakistani partition was on the same lines (hoping for self government), now do you think they are really developed after partition????

    I understand your ideology and I also understand Samaikhyandhra's ideology. Only that I can't support either.

    Unknown said...

    any proof for your less financial allotments on telangana region.

    Unknown said...

    During Kakatiya period, orugallu was Andhra capital, can u give back upto warangal to andhra, and IT development taken place from last 15 years only . so we also need revenue from IT Industries. Lot of Enggineering colleges/ MBBs colleges are there in HYD regions al these were developed in these 50 years only, so we have our right in our developed capital City. see if u had history of hyd , we also had the same from Kakatiya period. We also have our right in our telangana regions, So only we r struggling for samaikyandhra. Telangana udyamam kevalama swartham kosam, rajakiyam kosam chestunaru, please i request amayakula pranalu dayachesi teyyodhu.

    Post a Comment